Neuvottelija.com

Episode 423 · 2026-11-17 · 1:20:19 · Original in Finnish

Yalta 2: Putin, Xi and Trump | Arto Luukkanen | Neuvottelija 423

Originally published as “Jalta 2 Putin Xi Trump | Arto Luukkanen | Neuvottelija 423”

Docent Arto Luukkanen and Sami Miettinen compare the planned three-way meeting of Trump, Xi and Putin in China with the 1945 Yalta conference, where the great powers settled post-war Europe and the weak were left outside the room. In Luukkanen's reading, Russia turned the Abu Dhabi talks from peace in Ukraine to Europe's security order, seeking a US withdrawal from Europe, Finland out of NATO and the Baltic states emptied of troops. The conversation runs from Finland's exit from the war in 1944 and Ryti's personal commitment to Ribbentrop to the lopsided Sino-Russian alliance, Taiwan, the chip race and honey traps, the French election and Germany's reluctance to lead, and ends on Paasikivi's lesson: without strength you are treated as merchandise.

Guest: Arto Luukkanen · Host: Sami Miettinen

Watch and listen

Watch on YouTube JSON Markdown

Key moments

  1. 00:00 — The big three and the logic of force
  2. 01:30 — Arto Luukkanen and two black shirts
  3. 03:18 — Vladimir Putin, Donald Trump and Xi Jinping as a new Yalta
  4. 04:03 — What was agreed at Yalta in 1945
  5. 06:22 — Weak Europe is left out of the room
  6. 07:27 — Finland's road to peace in 1944
  7. 08:49 — Ryti's commitment and Ribbentrop's help
  8. 10:34 — Could Karelia have been kept?
  9. 12:08 — Trump's position after the midterms
  10. 13:22 — Abu Dhabi and Russia's demands on Europe
  11. 15:11 — A coalition of the willing without soldiers
  12. 16:38 — Russia's forces and the Baltics next
  13. 18:46 — Why Western companies fail in Russia
  14. 21:54 — Nvidia, Taiwan and the spy game
  15. 22:33 — Honey traps and KGB manuals
  16. 25:24 — China remembers the 1860 Convention of Peking
  17. 27:02 — Russia as China's younger brother
  18. 27:40 — Erdoğan, Turkey and the Ottoman dream
  19. 30:37 — Is Trump ready to sell Taiwan?
  20. 32:07 — Aleksandr Dugin and the war of world-views
  21. 34:06 — The oligarchs' lives and the Protestant ethic
  22. 35:50 — The French election and Marine Le Pen
  23. 37:48 — Sanna Marin and the victory of capitalism
  24. 39:05 — Taiwan's defence and chip production
  25. 41:06 — Will China or the United States win the AI race?
  26. 42:41 — Zheng He and Western expansiveness
  27. 44:12 — The East India Company and the tech giants
  28. 47:08 — Money decides great-power deals
  29. 48:45 — The Mandate of Heaven and the cycle of dynasties
  30. 51:09 — Mao, Deng and China's capacity for change
  31. 52:47 — Stalin's rehabilitation in today's Russia
  32. 54:09 — The Ukrainian front as the new prison camp
  33. 55:26 — The small homeland and the power of the babushkas
  34. 57:46 — When pensioners forced the government to back down
  35. 1:01:07 — Germany should wake from its sleep
  36. 1:03:57 — The rise of the left and the backlash
  37. 1:06:41 — The border law and the Social Democrats' vote
  38. 1:07:45 — Väinö Tanner and the legacy of sensible Social Democrats
  39. 1:11:08 — Lustration and the gas pipeline money
  40. 1:12:26 — The green left's children's party is over
  41. 1:14:19 — Paasikivi, Porkkala and the bag of sweets
  42. 1:15:43 — Negotiation begins with getting to the table
  43. 1:17:34 — France's debt and the threat of a euro crisis
  44. 1:19:20 — Thanks, and Luukkanen's Russia books in the Inner Circle

Summary

Who he is. Arto Luukkanen is a docent in Russian history and politics, the author of many books on Russia and a former party secretary of the Finns Party (2021–2023).

Yalta then. At Yalta in February 1945 Churchill, Roosevelt and Stalin agreed on Poland’s borders, the UN and Soviet entry into the war against Japan, with Poland absent. Luukkanen’s point is that Stalin decided wherever Soviet soldiers stood, whatever was written down. The percentages deal he describes was in fact made in Moscow in October 1944.

Yalta 2 now. A three-way Trump–Xi–Putin meeting has been prepared for the APEC summit in Shenzhen. Luukkanen argues that Russia used the November talks in Abu Dhabi to move from peace in Ukraine to Europe’s security order, while Europe, with a proposed reassurance force of 10,000–30,000 troops, has no “divisions” to bring to the table.

Finland 1944. The two retell how Finland kept a channel to Moscow open, held the summer offensive with German help bought by Ryti’s personal commitment to Ribbentrop, and then left the war without being occupied once Ryti resigned.

China and Russia. Luukkanen describes Russia as China’s “younger brother”, recalls the 1858 and 1860 land cessions China has not forgotten, and discusses Taiwan, the chip race, Xi’s military purges and the honey-trap affair around Nvidia’s Jensen Huang. Miettinen discloses that he owns Nvidia shares.

Europe’s choices. The episode ends on the French and Finnish elections, both on 18 April 2027, Germany’s need to wake up, Väinö Tanner’s legacy and Paasikivi’s lesson that a state without strength is treated as merchandise. The conversation continues in the members’ episode Neuvottelija Sisäpiiri 173.

Watch

The recording lives on the Neuvottelija channel: Jalta 2 Putin Xi Trump | Arto Luukkanen | Neuvottelija 423. A Finnish edition of this episode is published at www.neuvottelija.fi.

In depth

The Neuvottelija AI editions carry a long-form, fact-checked write-up of this episode: English · suomeksi.

Go deeper

Guides connected to this conversation, with frameworks and further reading.

People and topics

Guests: Arto Luukkanen

Topics: Geopolitics Negotiation

AI and agent resources


Source and content status

Provenance: Finnish source: Owner page assembled from YouTube metadata, the publisher's own description and chapter marks, translated one for one, and checked against the host's own Finnish caption track. The captions carry no speaker labels, so speakers were inferred from the conversation; quotations are translated for sense, not verbatim. No English caption track exists, so no transcript is published here. Historical claims were checked: the Yalta conference was held on 4-11 February 1945, the percentages agreement was made in Moscow on 9 October 1944 (not at Yalta) with different figures, the Fulton speech was in 1946, the 'wrong pig' remark is apocryphal, the Treaty of Nerchinsk favoured the Qing, and the great famine followed the Great Leap Forward, not the Cultural Revolution; Finland's 1944 dates, the Tornio alcohol-store episode, Porkkala and the 2005 pensioner protests were confirmed. Current events (the Abu Dhabi talks, Russia's offer of bilateral pacts, the Jensen Huang affair, the US midterm result, regional cuts to Russian death payments, the 18 April 2027 election dates) were checked against news reports; Luukkanen's list of Russian demands is his interpretation, and a claim about Krasnodar pensioners inviting Elon Musk could not be found. Luukkanen was Finns Party secretary in 2021-2023; Miettinen discloses that he owns Nvidia shares.. English subtitles: not available on this page; this is an episode summary, not a curated transcript. QA coverage 100% (transcript timecoded). Original episode: neuvottelija.fi. Imported 2026-11-17 · last reviewed 2026-11-17. Passages the source audio left genuinely ambiguous are marked [unclear] rather than guessed.